STRATUM 3 and 3E OSCILLATOR REQUIREMENTS
Stratum 3 and Stratum 3E oscillators have two frequency stability specifications (Free Run and Holdover). Bellcore has somewhat defined a third requirement, Drift. The Drift requirement is not per say a Bellcore specification. However Bellcore suggests that the Drift be used for calculating the Holdover specification and suggests Drift values.
ppm/20 years Stratum 3 and 3E)
The Free Run requirement is easily obtainable for any precision oscillator. However part of the system requirement is that any Stratum 3 and 3E system must be able to lock to any other stratum 3 or 3E system. The reference signal into the system may be from an operating free running system that can be off as much as ±4.6 ppm. Further clarifying the lock requirement, a Stratum 3E system must be able to lock to a Stratum 3 system. This means that a system where the VCO input of the oscillator in used to lock the frequency in the system, the oscillator in that system must be able to adjust ±4.6 ppm plus the stability of the oscillator. It is very difficult to design and build a Stratum 3 oscillator to pull ±9.2 ppm ( ±4.6 ppm for the oscillator in the system plus ±4.6 ppm for the reference signal into that system).
Holdover is the next easiest requirement. The Holdover requirement is defined to be over all possible conditions. These conditions include aging, temperature, voltage, and initial offset. Initial offset is how close the unit was locked to the reference signal at the time the signal was lost; not the initial frequency accuracy of the oscillator. Bellcore break down the Holdover requirement into 3 major components: Initial offset, Temperature, and Drift. Drift is explained in the next section. Bellcore suggests adding the Initial offset, Temperature and Drift to obtain the Holdover requirement. Their suggestion does not account for voltage changes, but alludes to it in the Drift calculation. If one is not concerned about the recommended Drift requirement and the temperature range is limited, then a TCXO could be used the Stratum 3 requirement. System designers have some flexibility in this area because:
The temperature range is not fully defined.
They can specify it in their system specification.
The suggested Drift value ids the most difficult to satisfy but is not a requirement. The temperature range is pseudo defined (Bell core suggest the temperature change in a lab environment of ± 5°F). The voltage change is alluded to because the Drift value is to include other effects along with aging and temperature. Since Drift is the tightest specification; aging, temperature, and voltage characteristics of the oscillator are large factors in this stability value. Usually TCXOs will not meet this value, because they usually do not have a frequency versus temperature characteristic that is as linear as an oven oscillator. Like the Holdover requirement, the system designer has some flexibility:In controlling the oscillator voltage by choice of power supply.
Specifying the temperature change for the Drift.
The system manufacturer has some flexibility in specifying the conditions of the Holdover and Drift values. Since Drift is not a requirement, it can be overlooked in the system specification. A limited temperature range for the Holdover could also be specified. The purchaser of system for end use should take into account the conditions of Holdover and Drift to determine the best value that will meet their requirements.
References: GR-1244-CORE, Clocks for the Synchronized Network: Common Generic Criteria,
Issue 1 ( Bellcore, June 1995)